Windy City Novelties currently has the $30 off voucher at the top of this page, which gives $30 off when you spend $299 or more and is best if you already plan to spend at least $299 and prefer entering a promo at checkout. That code cannot be used with any other offer, so it suits a single large purchase where a fixed $30 saving is acceptable.
Small baskets under $99: If your cart is below $99, the fixed threshold coupons do not apply. Use one of the percentage codes instead. For example, on a $60 order the 15% off code gives 15% off, taking $9 off and leaving $51, so the 15% code is the better choice. (Applies sitewide with a code.)
Baskets $99 to $198: You qualify for the $10 off with orders over $99 code, but a 15% off code usually saves more. For instance, on a $110 order the $10 off code drops the price to $100, while 15% off takes $16.50 off and leaves $93.50, so the 15% code gives the lower total. Use the $10 code only when a percentage code cannot be applied to the items in your cart.
Baskets $199 to $249: You can use the $20 off with orders over $199 or the $20 off over $200 code when your subtotal meets the threshold, but the 15% code still often beats a flat $20. On a $220 order 15% off reduces the total to $187.00 (a $33.00 saving), while a $20 off code leaves $200.00. Choose the 15% code for general merchandise unless an item is excluded from percentage discounts.
Baskets $249 to $298 (including custom imprint items): Custom imprint orders get automatic discounts such as $25 off over $249. If you are buying custom imprint items only, the $25 automatic discount will apply at checkout once your order reaches $249. For a $260 custom imprint order the $25 auto discount brings you to $235.00, while 15% off would reduce $260 to $221.00, so 15% still gives the lower total for that full cart. Use the $25 auto discount when you cannot use a promo code on those custom items.
Baskets $299 and above: The $30 off voucher at the top of this page becomes available at $299, but it cannot be combined with other offers. On a $320 order the $30 off code leaves $290.00, while 15% off leaves $272.00, so the 15% code gives the lower total. Pick the $30 code only if you cannot use the 15% code on your chosen items or prefer a guaranteed flat deduction.
Shipping and newsletter: Free shipping applies automatically to orders over $75, so factor that in when your cart reaches $75. The newsletter signup is useful for first time offers but is a signup only and not the main deal.
When choosing between the offers, take whichever option leaves you with the lower checkout total. Remember that the $30, $20 and $10 promo codes cannot be used with other offers, while the $25 and $15 custom imprint discounts are applied automatically to eligible custom imprint orders. If both a code and an automatic deal appear applicable, the terms that state a code cannot be used with other offers prevail, so use the single option that gives the lowest final price.