White Mountain Puzzles is running a strong promotion right now with a buy 3 get 1 free deal on selected items, making it the best headline offer for anyone stocking up on puzzles. Depending on what you're buying and how much you spend, other discounts might work better—so read through these scenarios to see which deal saves you the most.
Shopping for a single puzzle or small order: If you're only picking up one or two puzzles, the Buy 3 Get 1 Free deal won't apply. Instead, look for items from the Bestsellers range starting at $14.99, or check whether your chosen puzzles are included in the 20% Off Puzzles Sale or the Summer Sale: 20% Off Selected Puzzles to get the deepest discount on your smaller basket.
Buying multiple puzzles (3 or 4 items): This is where the Buy 3 Get 1 Free offer shines. If you're picking up exactly three puzzles, you get one completely free—a 25% saving on your total. If you're buying four puzzles and all four qualify, you still only pay for three, so it remains a strong option. Check that your selection is marked as eligible for this deal at checkout.
Larger orders (5+ puzzles or high total spend): Once your basket grows, compare the Buy 3 Get 1 Free offer against the other percentage discounts. The 20% Off Puzzles Sale and Summer Sale: 20% Off Selected Puzzles provide a consistent discount across qualifying items. The Up to 20% Off Bundles deal is also worth checking if you're buying puzzle sets or multi-packs. For any order over $75, don't forget that Free Shipping On Orders Over $75 applies, which sweetens the deal further.
Buying gift cards or specialty items: Gift cards start from $10 if you want to give the gift of puzzle choice. The 10% Off Artist Of The Month - David Maclean offer applies if you're interested in his designs specifically.
First time customers: If you haven't shopped with White Mountain Puzzles before, signing up to the newsletter for special offers and promotions can unlock additional first time buyer deals beyond what's listed here.
Remember that only one offer typically applies at checkout, so when you're ready to buy, add your items to your basket and compare the savings from each eligible offer. Choose whichever one gives you the biggest discount on your final total.