Petmate's main headline offer is 25% off selected beds, bowls, and toys. This deal works best for shoppers hunting for savings on these specific product categories, though your total order size will determine whether a different offer gives you more value.
For smaller orders under $75: If you're buying select beds, bowls, or toys, the 25% discount is your best bet. The newsletter signup may also be worth considering if you're a first time customer and want to explore additional promotions before committing to a purchase.
For orders between $75 and $100: You now have a choice between the 25% off selected items and the free gift with orders over $75. Calculate both at checkout: if your basket is heavy on the discounted beds, bowls, and toys, the 25% off will likely win. But if you're buying items outside these categories or a mix of products, the free gift over $75 threshold might deliver better value depending on what that gift is worth to you.
For orders over $100: The free gift offer on orders exceeding $100 becomes available alongside the other deals. Again, work through the math at checkout. If you're primarily buying the discounted beds, bowls, and toys and your subtotal sits just above $100, the 25% off those items will probably save you more than the free gift. However, if your cart includes other Petmate products outside the sale categories, the free gift threshold could be the stronger choice.
Remember that only one offer applies at checkout, so compare what each option delivers for your specific basket before finalizing your order. Take whichever produces the larger saving.