Ollie is showing a 70% off first box sale as the lead offer on the page: the 70% off your first box discount is applied automatically at checkout and is aimed at people buying their first box. That 70% off is the headline saving, and it is the best starting point if you are ordering your pet’s first box. The page also lists free gifts on your first box and two price marked plans from $1.57 and $1.00.
If this is your first box and you want the biggest percent saving, the 70% off your first box applies automatically at checkout and is the main choice. For example, on a Full Fresh box priced at $1.57, the 70% off reduces the price to $0.47, so you pay $0.47 and save $1.10. That is the clearest percent saving on a first box that shows a marked price.
If you prefer the lowest marked price regardless of percent off, choose the Half Fresh plan that starts at $1.00. That plan is described as a discounted first box and shows the price as marked, so you pay $1.00 for the box starting at that price. The Half Fresh plan at $1.00 is the cheapest marked starting price on the page for a first box.
If free extras matter more than the price, the free gifts on your first box are automatically included at checkout. They do not quote a dollar saving, so weigh the value of the gifts against the price options above when deciding.
If you are comparing the $1.57 full fresh option to the $1.00 half fresh option, the $1.00 marked price is lower than a $1.57 box after no discount. The 70% off on a $1.57 box lowers that box to $0.47, which is cheaper than the $1.00 half plan at its marked price. Use the 70% off if the 70% reduction applies to the particular box you want; otherwise pick the $1.00 half plan for the lowest marked outlay.
Our records show that the site has listed six offers for Ollie in the 12 months to October 2026, with the biggest percentage sale reaching up to 70% off, and our team completed one checkout test across one offer in that 12 month window. That means 70% off has appeared here before and was recorded as the biggest percentage deal in our database for the year.
When choosing between these options, pick the one that produces the lower total for the same box: the automatic 70% off on a first box will usually beat a marked $1.57 price, while the $1.00 marked half plan beats any higher marked price. There are no terms on the page that state explicit stacking rules, so treat each labeled offer on its own unless the checkout shows multiple offers applied.