Bully Sticks Central is running the Easter Day Sale: the 25% off promo code at the top of this page, applied at checkout. That code is best when you have a single order of treats or chews worth enough that a straight 25% saving beats the subscription or small order deals. If you plan to subscribe or use autoship, the 15% subscription discount may be a better long term choice for repeat purchases.
Small single orders under $65: use the 25% off promo code. On a $40 order, for example, the 25% code takes $10.00 off and leaves $30.00 to pay. The 5% off over $65 is not available here and the subscription savings require you to sign up.
Orders between $65 and $99: compare the 25% code with the 5% off over $65. For a $80 order, the 25% code reduces it to $60.00 (you save $20.00). The 5% promotion would cut $80 to $76.00 (you save $4.00), so the 25% code is better for single purchases in this band.
Orders $99 and above: the 25% code still usually wins for a one off order because 25% off is larger than 5% off. For a $120 order, the 25% code lowers the total to $90.00 (you save $30.00). Free shipping applies at $99, but whether the free shipping threshold is measured before or after a promo is not stated here, so treat the $99 threshold as the brand states it.
If you plan to subscribe or use autoship: the 15% subscription or autoship discount applies to recurring bully stick orders. If you expect to reorder regularly, use the 15% subscription offer for ongoing savings on each rebill; on a $100 recurring order, 15% off brings it to $85.00 (you save $15.00 each time). The Easter 25% code is a single use per checkout and remains the page lead, but subscription rates apply only to subscribers.
When buying marked deals or single priced items: items priced as marked, such as collagen sticks at $16.99, chicken sausage at $13.99, beef tendons at $9.99, or sampler packs from $32.99, are often already discounted. The collagen, chicken and beef deals state they cannot be used with any other offers, so you cannot combine those fixed price deals with the 25% code. If a marked item can accept the code, the 25% off will reduce its listed price at checkout.
Our records show 21 offers listed for the brand in the 12 months to November 2026, with only one percentage code in that time and the biggest being 25% off. Our team carried out 1 checkout test of a Bully Sticks Central offer in the 12 months to November 2026 and saved a screenshot as proof.
Choose the option that leaves you the lower total. For a one time cart the 25% off promo code at the top of the page will usually give the biggest immediate saving; if you will reorder regularly, take the 15% subscription/autoship rate. Remember the collagen, chicken and beef listed deals expressly cannot be used with other offers, so do not expect them to combine.