ButcherBox is offering $20 off your order with the featured promo code at the top of this page. This code works on any order size and is the strongest fixed discount currently live. For customers buying a larger basket, you should compare it against the 15% off code to see which saves you more.
On a small order under $135, the $20 off code gives you the bigger saving. If you're placing your first order from ButcherBox, you can use the $10 off first box code instead, though the $20 code is still stronger on most baskets. First time customers who want to test a smaller order might prefer the $10 discount to lower their initial spend, but the $20 code costs you less money.
On an order of $135 or more, the 15% off code starts to save more than the $20 fixed discount. On a $200 order, for example, 15% off brings you to $170, a saving of $30, compared to $20 off bringing you to $180. The bigger your basket, the more the 15% code pulls ahead.
The $100 off plus free steaks deal sits above both codes on paper, but it is limited to stock availability and appears to be a promotion rather than a guaranteed offer. If you can add it to your cart, take it; otherwise use the code that matches your spending tier.
Our team tested 7 ButcherBox promo codes at checkout in the 12 months to November 2026, with 4 tests backed by screenshots. In that period, the typical code was 15% off and the biggest percentage offer was 20% off in May 2026, so the current codes track with ButcherBox's recent offer history.
To choose between the $20 code and the 15% code, calculate both savings on your cart total and take whichever leaves you paying less. Neither code is restricted by minimum spend, so the math is straightforward. If you're signing up to the newsletter, note that a $50 off first box code ended on 1 October 2026, so check back here or sign up to Love Coupons alerts if you want to catch the next big first order offer.